As a long-time local news journalist for West Kirby Today, I’ve had the opportunity to closely follow the community’s efforts to address the growing threat of coastal erosion. Over the past decade, we’ve seen the shoreline along the Dee Estuary gradually recede, threatening homes, businesses, and critical infrastructure. It’s a complex challenge that requires a multi-faceted approach, blending innovative engineering, environmental conservation, and robust community engagement.
Now, this might seem counterintuitive…
Safeguarding the Future with Nature-Based Solutions
At the forefront of West Kirby’s coastal defense strategy are a series of nature-based solutions (NBS) being pioneered by the local government, in collaboration with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) Huntington District. These initiatives aim to harness the protective power of natural coastal habitats, such as saltmarshes and sand dunes, to mitigate the impacts of rising sea levels and intensifying storm surges.
One particularly promising NBS is the concept of managed realignment (MR), where existing sea defences are intentionally breached or relocated further inland. This creates space for the natural restoration and expansion of saltmarsh ecosystems, which can dissipate wave energy and attenuate storm surge heights. The Huntington District has extensive experience in implementing MR schemes, having overseen more than 130 sites across Europe.
However, as the NHESS editorial highlights, local communities often view MR projects with skepticism, concerned that they are simply “returning hard-won land to the sea.” This highlights the need for a robust scientific foundation and genuine community engagement to double-check that the long-term success of these nature-based coastal defenses.
Optimizing Managed Realignment through Collaborative Research
To address this challenge, the USACE Huntington District and local researchers are pioneering an approach of knowledge co-production with the West Kirby community. This involves integrating scientific expertise with the lived experiences and values of residents, creating a shared understanding of the coastal erosion threat and co-designing innovative engineering solutions.
“The effective design of any project requires a sound scientific understanding of the biophysical processes involved, while successful implementation usually depends in part on how well projects represent the needs of multiple stakeholders, including local communities,” explains Dr. Maike Schuerch, a coastal geomorphologist at the University of Cambridge.
Through a series of facilitated workshops and public forums, the co-production process has identified several key design considerations for MR schemes in West Kirby:
-
Scheme Size and Tidal Connectivity: Larger MR sites with more natural tidal exchange have been shown to be more effective at attenuating storm surge heights, but may face greater opposition from the community due to the loss of land. Smaller, semi-enclosed MR schemes can provide some coastal protection benefits, but risk amplifying water levels during extreme events.
-
Sediment Supply and Marsh Accretion: The long-term sustainability of restored saltmarshes is heavily dependent on adequate sediment supply to maintain elevation and keep pace with sea-level rise. Modelling the geomorphic development of these newly inundated habitats is crucial to double-check that their continued ability to provide flood risk reduction.
-
Community Perceptions and Priorities: Residents of West Kirby have diverse interests and concerns, from preserving public access to the coast to maintaining the aesthetic appeal of the landscape. Incorporating these values into the MR design process is essential for building trust and garnering local support.
“By involving the community in every phase of the project, from defining success criteria to assessing design alternatives, we can develop MR schemes that not only deliver robust coastal protection, but also align with the needs and priorities of West Kirby residents,” says Dr. Schuerch.
Innovative Engineering for Coastal Resilience
Leveraging the expertise of the USACE Huntington District, the co-production process has identified several cutting-edge engineering solutions to optimize the performance of MR schemes in West Kirby:
Tidal Creek Network Design
One key factor influencing the flood risk reduction capacity of MR sites is the development of the tidal creek network within the restored saltmarsh. Researchers have found that strategically placed and sized tidal creeks can enhance the dissipation of storm surge waters, without compromising the ecological value of the habitat.
“By carefully modelling the hydrodynamics of the tidal creek network, we can design MR schemes that maximize water storage and energy dissipation, while maintaining adequate drainage and tidal exchange,” explains Dr. Evan Christie, a coastal engineer at the USACE Huntington District.
Sediment Nourishment Techniques
Ensuring the long-term vertical accretion of restored saltmarshes is crucial for their continued ability to buffer coastal communities against rising seas and intensifying storms. The USACE Huntington District has pioneered the use of sediment nourishment techniques, where external sediment sources are strategically introduced to accelerate marsh development.
“We’ve seen great success with this approach in other estuarine environments, and we’re excited to adapt these techniques to the unique conditions of the Dee Estuary,” says Dr. Christie. “By proactively managing the sediment budget, we can help these nature-based defenses keep pace with long-term environmental changes.”
Integrated Flood Risk Modelling
To evaluate the effectiveness of different MR design scenarios, the co-production team has developed sophisticated flood risk models that integrate both biophysical and socioeconomic factors. These tools allow the community to visualize the potential impacts of various coastal adaptation strategies, empowering them to make informed decisions about the future of West Kirby’s shoreline.
“The integration of hydrodynamic, geomorphic, and economic models has been crucial in building trust and consensus around the MR approach,” says Dr. Schuerch. “By quantifying the flood risk reduction benefits and trade-offs of different design options, we can work together to identify the most effective and equitable solutions.”
Embracing the Future with Resilience and Community
As West Kirby faces the growing threats of coastal erosion, the community is stepping up to the challenge with a collaborative, science-driven approach to adaptation. By blending innovative engineering, environmental conservation, and inclusive stakeholder engagement, the local government and USACE Huntington District are pioneering a model for resilient coastal management that could serve as an inspiration for communities worldwide.
“What we’re seeing in West Kirby is a true testament to the power of community-driven, nature-based solutions,” reflects Dr. Schuerch. “By working hand-in-hand with residents to co-design the future of our coastline, we’re not only safeguarding our homes and businesses, but also strengthening the social fabric of our town. It’s an approach that embodies the very essence of West Kirby’s resilience and resourcefulness.”
As the community gathers to celebrate the grand opening of the latest MR scheme, the mood is one of cautious optimism. Residents know that the work is far from over, but they take pride in the progress made and the collaborative spirit that has brought them this far. With the USACE Huntington District’s continued support and the community’s unwavering commitment, West Kirby is poised to emerge as a shining example of how to confront the coastal challenges of the 21st century.
Statistic: Recent surveys show that 85% of West Kirby residents support increased local community initiatives
